Burger is obviously a better run generator due to his pop. You're also going to get a lot more opportunity to create runs when you're batting 2-5. I also do tend to give more credit to power hitters than bWAR and fWAR does as I think they value defense too much.Pharmabro wrote: ↑Thu Oct 24, 2024 5:44 amOn Rojas vs Burger it is combined runs and RBI the last 2 years.D-train wrote: ↑Wed Oct 23, 2024 11:17 pm.5 bWAR and 29 bombs is almost impossible to do. His D is HORRID. btw Rojas had 2.1 bWAR. lolSeattle or Bust wrote: ↑Wed Oct 23, 2024 6:55 pmDiaz and Lowe are fine.
I don't see the M's ever giving that kind of money for a reliever. If they wanted Scott that bad, they woulda traded for him over Yimi.
Burger is a nothing burger to me. I don't get the hype. .5 bWAR and 1.4 fWAR while hanging 29 homers is concerning.
Burger RBI=156, Runs 139 /278 games (91 RBI/162 & 81 runs/162)
Rojas RBI= 71, Runs = 95,/247 games (47 RBI/162 & 62 runs/162)
Rojas drives in runs at 1/2 the rate. It is closer than the raw #'s because Rojas only double dipped on HR RBI + a run but even so. And, IF Perry Hill is unable to improve his keystone corner D like he did with Geno, Rojas, and others you could slide over Dilly and DH Burger. Burger is actually much faster than he looks (27.9 FPS) which is equal to JK.
I think Perry could mold him into at least passable defense and you would get a 3-4 WAR-guy for doing so.
I admit it is far-fetched to see the organization spring for an elite left-handed guy instead of trying to do their find them and fix them routine. But I have not seen them be able to get premium performing lefties: Saucedo's 106 ERA+ was the only one with his head above water at all this year.
You have to go back to 2018 when Roenis Elias tossed a 154 ERA+, and James Pazos had a 142 to find a lefty having a good year in our pen. That is 6 years with out a lefty having a 125 ERA+ or better in the top dozen or so BP guys.
So, yes go get a good lefty AJ Minter, or find a lefty version of the Gregory Santos deal but get it done.
Oh, and Josh Rojas has a 27 FPS time on the year.
All said, Josh Rojas shouldn't be the standard you're measuring against offensively. Their hitting profiles are nowhere close to the same and it's a failure on Jerry's part to put such a weakling at a power position.