Drew will start but that is a pretty insane analogy. A guy who just won the SB vs. a guy that won 3 games vs. bad teams compared to two rookies...I guess Flynn had a good Garbage time game the prior season....XpertDBA wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 9:00 pmI just don't get how any sane person can watch Sam and watch Lock and not be pissed if they start Sam against the 49ers.
It's not even a close decision at this point. I really don't get starting Sam, unless MM is just too afraid of Sam being a fucking baby and not accepting the news well. Pete Carrol once grew some balls, and decided to start Russell Wilson over Matt Flynn. MM needs to grow a pair. Fuck Sam Darnold.
Post Mortem: Seattle v Loss Vegas
Re: Post Mortem: Seattle v Loss Vegas
dt
-
DanielVogelbach
- Posts: 1536
- Joined: Sat Jun 08, 2019 7:43 pm
Re: Post Mortem: Seattle v Loss Vegas
I think there are some valid points on either side of the Lock vs Sam debate.
Right now, though, my vote is for Lock. Mistake free QB seems to be what they need, and Lock seems less likely to do something stupid. Secondly, I just like Lock. It seems like he gets more fired up to play. More emotion.
Right now, though, my vote is for Lock. Mistake free QB seems to be what they need, and Lock seems less likely to do something stupid. Secondly, I just like Lock. It seems like he gets more fired up to play. More emotion.
Re: Post Mortem: Seattle v Loss Vegas
Agree, and it isn't like Lock is a game manager. Dude can ball and totally agree he is a lot easier to root for given his charisma....DanielVogelbach wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 1:12 amI think there are some valid points on either side of the Lock vs Sam debate.
Right now, though, my vote is for Lock. Mistake free QB seems to be what they need, and Lock seems less likely to do something stupid. Secondly, I just like Lock. It seems like he gets more fired up to play. More emotion.
dt
Re: Post Mortem: Seattle v Loss Vegas
Agreed both sides have valid points. I lean into Darnold for a few reasons. We know what he can do, we know he carried the load down the stretch last year, we know he can win a chip. This year he started off injured, lost the RB room, oline injuries, and a newe OC - that is a LOT to have thrown at you. I think teams have inherant philosophies - like moving on from walker - to you don't lose your job due to injury - and you stick to them. You have to ignore the talking heads and run your philosophy. You see 'your guy' get handed a shit sandwich and you bail on him? That's sending a bad message to the team. Ignore the noise, stay the course.DanielVogelbach wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 1:12 amI think there are some valid points on either side of the Lock vs Sam debate.
Right now, though, my vote is for Lock. Mistake free QB seems to be what they need, and Lock seems less likely to do something stupid. Secondly, I just like Lock. It seems like he gets more fired up to play. More emotion.
I like Lock, he's been great - but he's not the future. He's playing with no pressure right now, but down the stretch, could he have won those Rams games? I don't know. Right now he's the exactly what we need in replacement - long term I don't know his ceiling. Right now we have an enviable situation and that should be a huge shout out to JS who has given this team wicked depth. Few teams have a capable back up like we do.
Let's remember Lock has gone up against Patriots, Cards, Cards and Raiders - not elite units. Darnold has had to face much stiffer competition. Does anyone seriously think Seattle wins the greatest Thursday NIght Game ever with Lock? Not taking anything away from what he's done, but let's have some perspective here.
Am I also nervous about Sam? Yup. 100%.
I expect The Darnold to regain the gig upon a clean bill of health. All the knee jerk reactions and short term thinking will be ignored. Just like Walker - JS made the smart decision by playing the LONG GAME. It sure is fun watching Lock, a breath oif fresh air, but I don't think Sam has been healthy since that first game and that may be a huge underlying factor in his performance. You cannot ignore all he's been handed and just give the keys to the shiny toy. Yeah, he's had gaffes, our replacement RB fumbles also cost us dearly - 100% cost us the SF game. When I add it all up I just see him getting the keys back, and that is not absolving his bad play at times - I do beleive there is more to it than people are acknowledging because they want the shiny toy RIGHT NOW!
Re: Post Mortem: Seattle v Loss Vegas
I just think the 49er game is a must win, no matter what. And you ride the hot hand while its hot. You don't put in the guy who's afraid of his own shadow at this point.auroraave wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 3:03 amAgreed both sides have valid points. I lean into Darnold for a few reasons. We know what he can do, we know he carried the load down the stretch last year, we know he can win a chip. This year he started off injured, lost the RB room, oline injuries, and a newe OC - that is a LOT to have thrown at you. I think teams have inherant philosophies - like moving on from walker - to you don't lose your job due to injury - and you stick to them. You have to ignore the talking heads and run your philosophy. You see 'your guy' get handed a shit sandwich and you bail on him? That's sending a bad message to the team. Ignore the noise, stay the course.DanielVogelbach wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 1:12 amI think there are some valid points on either side of the Lock vs Sam debate.
Right now, though, my vote is for Lock. Mistake free QB seems to be what they need, and Lock seems less likely to do something stupid. Secondly, I just like Lock. It seems like he gets more fired up to play. More emotion.
I like Lock, he's been great - but he's not the future. He's playing with no pressure right now, but down the stretch, could he have won those Rams games? I don't know. Right now he's the exactly what we need in replacement - long term I don't know his ceiling. Right now we have an enviable situation and that should be a huge shout out to JS who has given this team wicked depth. Few teams have a capable back up like we do.
Let's remember Lock has gone up against Patriots, Cards, Cards and Raiders - not elite units. Darnold has had to face much stiffer competition. Does anyone seriously think Seattle wins the greatest Thursday NIght Game ever with Lock? Not taking anything away from what he's done, but let's have some perspective here.
Am I also nervous about Sam? Yup. 100%.
I expect The Darnold to regain the gig upon a clean bill of health. All the knee jerk reactions and short term thinking will be ignored. Just like Walker - JS made the smart decision by playing the LONG GAME. It sure is fun watching Lock, a breath oif fresh air, but I don't think Sam has been healthy since that first game and that may be a huge underlying factor in his performance. You cannot ignore all he's been handed and just give the keys to the shiny toy. Yeah, he's had gaffes, our replacement RB fumbles also cost us dearly - 100% cost us the SF game. When I add it all up I just see him getting the keys back, and that is not absolving his bad play at times - I do beleive there is more to it than people are acknowledging because they want the shiny toy RIGHT NOW!
Re: Post Mortem: Seattle v Loss Vegas
How exactly does Lock have 'the hot hand"? We just scored a paltry 21 on the worst defense in the league. He's played (and won!) vs terrible teams. Why is that not acknowledged? Do you honeslty think Lock beats the Lambs down the stretch last year?
If Darnold is healthy I would be shocked if Lock gets the start. This is the NFL, you don't drop your starting QB coming off injury because his back up scored 21 vs the worst team in the league - the cardinals are no better. No coaching staff would do that. DOn't bother with the Brady analogy - NE didn't win the SB the previous year. YOu have to have consistancy - even if it fails you have to stay the course until proven it doesn't work.
By the way, this is my fav part, if Lock is 'so hot' right now, where is all the Fleury praise?
Make no mistake, I am not 'team darnold', I'm simply rejecting the 'hot hand' theory and the idea of throwing out QB 1 because of that illusion. I do not see the team keeping a HEALTHY Darnold on the bench - for better or worse. Rememebr the stretch run last year where he was unbeatable. DO you really think Lock pulls that off? Zero evidence he could have - but we KNOW Darnold CAN. That's the hand you go with, IMO.
ALso, if Lock starts and falls apart - then what? You just blew up any confidence Darnold could have coming back. How do you handle that?
Everyone seems to only ever play the short game. Something else to consider - Darnolds turnovers aside - if all out back up RB's didn't fumble - especially the SF drop in the end zone - not only do we likely win that game - this is a whole different scenario. It wasn't all on Darnold. Something else conveniently overlooked in all of this. How much additional stress was put on Darnold by the RB's fumbling early on?
If Darnold is healthy I would be shocked if Lock gets the start. This is the NFL, you don't drop your starting QB coming off injury because his back up scored 21 vs the worst team in the league - the cardinals are no better. No coaching staff would do that. DOn't bother with the Brady analogy - NE didn't win the SB the previous year. YOu have to have consistancy - even if it fails you have to stay the course until proven it doesn't work.
By the way, this is my fav part, if Lock is 'so hot' right now, where is all the Fleury praise?
Make no mistake, I am not 'team darnold', I'm simply rejecting the 'hot hand' theory and the idea of throwing out QB 1 because of that illusion. I do not see the team keeping a HEALTHY Darnold on the bench - for better or worse. Rememebr the stretch run last year where he was unbeatable. DO you really think Lock pulls that off? Zero evidence he could have - but we KNOW Darnold CAN. That's the hand you go with, IMO.
ALso, if Lock starts and falls apart - then what? You just blew up any confidence Darnold could have coming back. How do you handle that?
Everyone seems to only ever play the short game. Something else to consider - Darnolds turnovers aside - if all out back up RB's didn't fumble - especially the SF drop in the end zone - not only do we likely win that game - this is a whole different scenario. It wasn't all on Darnold. Something else conveniently overlooked in all of this. How much additional stress was put on Darnold by the RB's fumbling early on?
Re: Post Mortem: Seattle v Loss Vegas
Great write-up as always, and I am in the Lock camp. Whether it is injuries or injuries combined with his natural tendency for picks and fumbles, Darnold has been shit this year. His stats are flat ugly. To throw him back in against a red-hot Whiners' team on the road --after nearly a month on the shelf -- is just begging for another two-pick, one fumble disaster.
Happy to be wrong if he gets the start, but Lock is doing almost everything right in the games he's been in this year. He kind of reminds me of Dave Krieg, Mudbone. Not super-flashy, but he gets the W. He's earned the start on the 29th. The Hawks aren't stupid; they can see the stats as well as we can. Hope they just say that Sam isn't 100% and is still battling injuries. Doubt that will happen, though. I think they they'll start Sam and if he continues to tank and we miss the playoffs, I recall that there is an escape-hatch on his contract for next season.
https://www.espn.com/nfl/player/gamelog ... am-darnold
https://www.espn.com/nfl/player/gamelog ... /drew-lock
Happy to be wrong if he gets the start, but Lock is doing almost everything right in the games he's been in this year. He kind of reminds me of Dave Krieg, Mudbone. Not super-flashy, but he gets the W. He's earned the start on the 29th. The Hawks aren't stupid; they can see the stats as well as we can. Hope they just say that Sam isn't 100% and is still battling injuries. Doubt that will happen, though. I think they they'll start Sam and if he continues to tank and we miss the playoffs, I recall that there is an escape-hatch on his contract for next season.
https://www.espn.com/nfl/player/gamelog ... am-darnold
https://www.espn.com/nfl/player/gamelog ... /drew-lock
Re: Post Mortem: Seattle v Loss Vegas
He was 14 of 17 and with 2 dropped passes that hit the receivers square in the hands. He leads the league in pass percentage completion. If that's not HOT, then I really don't know what is. Not to mention he had several key scrambles, including the one leading to the amazing pass to Kupp. Geez, are you even watching the games?auroraave wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 4:31 pmHow exactly does Lock have 'the hot hand"? We just scored a paltry 21 on the worst defense in the league. He's played (and won!) vs terrible teams. Why is that not acknowledged? Do you honeslty think Lock beats the Lambs down the stretch last year?
If Darnold is healthy I would be shocked if Lock gets the start. This is the NFL, you don't drop your starting QB coming off injury because his back up scored 21 vs the worst team in the league - the cardinals are no better. No coaching staff would do that. DOn't bother with the Brady analogy - NE didn't win the SB the previous year. YOu have to have consistancy - even if it fails you have to stay the course until proven it doesn't work.
By the way, this is my fav part, if Lock is 'so hot' right now, where is all the Fleury praise?
Make no mistake, I am not 'team darnold', I'm simply rejecting the 'hot hand' theory and the idea of throwing out QB 1 because of that illusion. I do not see the team keeping a HEALTHY Darnold on the bench - for better or worse. Rememebr the stretch run last year where he was unbeatable. DO you really think Lock pulls that off? Zero evidence he could have - but we KNOW Darnold CAN. That's the hand you go with, IMO.
ALso, if Lock starts and falls apart - then what? You just blew up any confidence Darnold could have coming back. How do you handle that?
Everyone seems to only ever play the short game. Something else to consider - Darnolds turnovers aside - if all out back up RB's didn't fumble - especially the SF drop in the end zone - not only do we likely win that game - this is a whole different scenario. It wasn't all on Darnold. Something else conveniently overlooked in all of this. How much additional stress was put on Darnold by the RB's fumbling early on?
Also, if Sam starts and falls apart - then what? You just blew a chance to gain ground against the leading team. All I see from Sam lately is a scared pathetic version of a QB who can't keep from turning the ball over. He's done that his whole career, do you think that's ever going to really change?