He was 27th in WAR among starting pitchers in 2026 which is good although it seems very misleading. He has a career WHIP of 1.063 which is close to as good as you get over a six-year period, yet he has a career ERA of 3.60 which for a guy pitching half his games at T-Mobile is very average. A guy with a WHIP like that should have a career ERA of about 2.60. Seriously, this guy should be in the Cy Young running most of the time yet he never is. He's not going to be worth the money he's going to demand and thankfully he's replacable.Captain 97 wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 7:27 pmAwe yes the old eye test.By definition there at least 60 #1 and #2 Starters in the league. By any objective measurement there are not anywhere close to 60 starting pitchers better than Gilbert. There aren't even 30.
2026-27 Hot Stove Thread
-
DavidGee24
- Posts: 11852
- Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 6:24 pm
- Location: Phillips Ranch, CA
Re: 2026-27 Hot Stove Thread
Re: 2026-27 Hot Stove Thread
Seems pretty quiet on Rumor front. Been watching from around the world and left with nothing every day. From the future as Tuesday 11/17 at 0645 nothing new to report
-
Captain 97
- Posts: 3980
- Joined: Mon May 06, 2019 9:23 pm
Re: 2026-27 Hot Stove Thread
Yeah I don't think that Jerry will open the purse strings for him and I actually don't have a problem with that. I would like to see him traded for a legitimate young bat if possible. I'd also like to see Miller Traded. I don't think he has the durability to stick in the rotation long term.
I think we have enough starting pitching depth to sustain those losses as long as we can assemble a legitimate MLB offense in return.
Re: 2026-27 Hot Stove Thread
Decent take.
FWIW Logan Gilbert and Seiya Suzuki reportedly are both represented by THE TEAM agency.
Re: 2026-27 Hot Stove Thread
I could be spacing but when was the last time one year of a TOR was traded for a legitimate MLB ready controllable bat?Captain 97 wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 10:35 pmYeah I don't think that Jerry will open the purse strings for him and I actually don't have a problem with that. I would like to see him traded for a legitimate young bat if possible. I'd also like to see Miller Traded. I don't think he has the durability to stick in the rotation long term.
I think we have enough starting pitching depth to sustain those losses as long as we can assemble a legitimate MLB offense in return.
That is what I never get about these simplistic trade proposals. Just trade one of our starters for and awesome bat!!! Why would a team want to give up a great bat if they are contending. And if they aren't contending why would they want a Rental TOR?????
They only way they would is if like the O's have a surplus and then we get Westburg instead of Henderson,..
dt
-
Captain 97
- Posts: 3980
- Joined: Mon May 06, 2019 9:23 pm
Re: 2026-27 Hot Stove Thread
Three team deals are a thing. Trade Logan for a Prospect. Flip the prospect for a bat.D-train wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 1:19 amI could be spacing but when was the last time one year of a TOR was traded for a legitimate MLB ready controllable bat?Captain 97 wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 10:35 pmYeah I don't think that Jerry will open the purse strings for him and I actually don't have a problem with that. I would like to see him traded for a legitimate young bat if possible. I'd also like to see Miller Traded. I don't think he has the durability to stick in the rotation long term.
I think we have enough starting pitching depth to sustain those losses as long as we can assemble a legitimate MLB offense in return.
That is what I never get about these simplistic trade proposals. Just trade one of our starters for and awesome bat!!! Why would a team want to give up a great bat if they are contending. And if they aren't contending why would they want a Rental TOR?????
They only way they would is if like the O's have a surplus and then we get Westburg instead of Henderson,..
-
Captain 97
- Posts: 3980
- Joined: Mon May 06, 2019 9:23 pm
Re: 2026-27 Hot Stove Thread
How about this.
Red Sox get:
Logan
M's Get:
Elly
Reds Get:
Justin Gonzalez.
Cole Young
Laz Montez
Michael Arroyo
Red Sox get:
Logan
M's Get:
Elly
Reds Get:
Justin Gonzalez.
Cole Young
Laz Montez
Michael Arroyo
Re: 2026-27 Hot Stove Thread
That is just insanely bad. M's give up Logan, Cole, Laz, AND Arroyo for a player that struggles to field the ball and does not hit consistently at one of the best hitting ballparks in baseball. Sure, when he hits, he is dynamic, but you are giving up way too much for him.Captain 97 wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 5:33 pmHow about this.
Red Sox get:
Logan
M's Get:
Elly
Reds Get:
Justin Gonzalez.
Cole Young
Laz Montez
Michael Arroyo
Re: 2026-27 Hot Stove Thread
Here is a list of possible non-tenders. Royce Lewis kind of jumps off the list for me. Obviously, this will be the dumpster diving list Jerry will use
Catchers
Joey Bart (White Sox): $2.9MM
Nick Fortes (Rays): $3.4MM
Rafael Marchán (Phillies): $1MM
Bo Naylor (Brewers): $1.5MM
Logan O’Hoppe (Rangers): $3.1MM
Connor Wong (Red Sox): $2MM
First Basemen
Jake Burger (Rangers): $6.9MM
Triston Casas (Red Sox): $1.7MM
Royce Lewis (Twins): $5.1MM
Christopher Morel (Mets): $2.1MM
Mark Vientos (Mets): $2.4MM
Second Basemen
Romy Gonzalez (Red Sox): $1.8MM
Matt McLain (Reds): $4MM
Richie Palacios (Rays): $2MM
Oswald Peraza (Angels): $1.4MM
Josh Smith (Blue Jays): $3.7MM
Third Basemen
Nolan Gorman (Cardinals): $3.4MM
Zach McKinstry (Tigers): $5MM
Shortstops
Gabriel Arias (Cubs): $1.3MM
Andruw Monasterio (Red Sox): $1.6MM
Jared Triolo (Pirates): $1.8MM
Center Fielders
Kyle Isbel (Royals): $3.5MM
Blake Perkins (Guardians): $900K
Jose Siri (Angels): $2.3MM
Eli White (Red Sox): $1.4MM
Corner Outfielders
Jo Adell (Guardians): $9.6MM
Akil Baddoo (Pirates): $1.3MM
Jordan Beck (Rockies): $1.2MM
JJ Bleday (Reds): $4.8MM
Alex Call (Dodgers): $1.9MM
Bryan De La Cruz (Phillies): $1.2MM
Jarren Duran (Red Sox): $11.1MM
David Fry (Guardians): $1.9MM
Jahmai Jones (Red Sox): $900K
Josh Lowe (Angels): $3.6MM
Brandon Marsh (Phillies): $8.3MM
Wenceel Pérez (Tigers): $1.4MM
Luke Raley (Mariners): $3.1MM
Davis Schneider (Blue Jays): $1.3MM
Gavin Sheets (Padres): $6.5MM
Taylor Trammell (Astros): $1.5MM
Matt Vierling (Tigers): $3.7MM
Starting Pitchers
Ronel Blanco (Astros): $1.4MM
Kutter Crawford (Red Sox): $2.8MM
Ryan Feltner (Rockies): $3.8MM
Bowden Francis (Blue Jays): $1.3MM
Braxton Garrett (Cubs): $1.6MM
Luis Gil (Yankees): $2.3MM
Josiah Gray (Nationals): $1.6MM
Tanner Houck (Red Sox): $4.1MM
Jake Irvin (Nationals): $3.4MM
Tylor Megill (Mets): $2.5MM
Bailey Ober (Twins): $6.9MM
Mitchell Parker (Braves): $1.1MM
Grayson Rodriguez (Angels): $2.1MM
Jesse Scholtens (Rays): $900K
JP Sears (Padres): $2.8MM
Joey Wentz (Braves): $900K
Brandon Williamson (Reds): $1.3MM
Right-Handed Relievers
Jake Bird (Nationals): $1.3MM
Beau Brieske (Tigers): $1.5MM
Jhony Brito (Padres): $800K
José Buttó (Rangers): $800K
Jake Cousins (Dodgers): $1MM
Cooper Criswell (Mariners): $900K
Camilo Doval (Giants): $6.6MM
Lucas Erceg (Royals): $2.3MM
Michael Grove (Braves): $1MM
Jimmy Herget (Rockies): $2.4MM
Bryan Hoeing (Padres): $800K
James Karinchak (Braves): $1.1MM
Jordan Leasure (White Sox): $1MM
James McArthur (Royals): $800K
Nick Mears (Royals): $2.2MM
Nate Pearson (Royals): $2MM
Ethan Roberts (Cubs): $800K
Manuel Rodríguez (Rays): $900K
Michael Rucker (Mariners): $800K
Cole Sands (Twins): $1.3MM
Tony Santillan (Reds): $2.5MM
Cole Sulser (Rays): $1.9MM
Edwin Uceta (Rays): $1.5MM
Will Vest (Tigers): $4.4MM
Rowan Wick (Giants): $800K
Left-Handed Relievers
Tanner Banks (Phillies): $1.4MM
Garrett Cleavinger (Rays): $3.7MM
Anthony Gose (Royals): $1.1MM
Chris Murphy (White Sox): $900K
Andrew Nardi (Marlins): $1.1MM
Cionel Pérez (Mets): $1.2MM
Bennett Sousa (Astros): $1.3MM
https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2026/11/ ... dates.html
Catchers
Joey Bart (White Sox): $2.9MM
Nick Fortes (Rays): $3.4MM
Rafael Marchán (Phillies): $1MM
Bo Naylor (Brewers): $1.5MM
Logan O’Hoppe (Rangers): $3.1MM
Connor Wong (Red Sox): $2MM
First Basemen
Jake Burger (Rangers): $6.9MM
Triston Casas (Red Sox): $1.7MM
Royce Lewis (Twins): $5.1MM
Christopher Morel (Mets): $2.1MM
Mark Vientos (Mets): $2.4MM
Second Basemen
Romy Gonzalez (Red Sox): $1.8MM
Matt McLain (Reds): $4MM
Richie Palacios (Rays): $2MM
Oswald Peraza (Angels): $1.4MM
Josh Smith (Blue Jays): $3.7MM
Third Basemen
Nolan Gorman (Cardinals): $3.4MM
Zach McKinstry (Tigers): $5MM
Shortstops
Gabriel Arias (Cubs): $1.3MM
Andruw Monasterio (Red Sox): $1.6MM
Jared Triolo (Pirates): $1.8MM
Center Fielders
Kyle Isbel (Royals): $3.5MM
Blake Perkins (Guardians): $900K
Jose Siri (Angels): $2.3MM
Eli White (Red Sox): $1.4MM
Corner Outfielders
Jo Adell (Guardians): $9.6MM
Akil Baddoo (Pirates): $1.3MM
Jordan Beck (Rockies): $1.2MM
JJ Bleday (Reds): $4.8MM
Alex Call (Dodgers): $1.9MM
Bryan De La Cruz (Phillies): $1.2MM
Jarren Duran (Red Sox): $11.1MM
David Fry (Guardians): $1.9MM
Jahmai Jones (Red Sox): $900K
Josh Lowe (Angels): $3.6MM
Brandon Marsh (Phillies): $8.3MM
Wenceel Pérez (Tigers): $1.4MM
Luke Raley (Mariners): $3.1MM
Davis Schneider (Blue Jays): $1.3MM
Gavin Sheets (Padres): $6.5MM
Taylor Trammell (Astros): $1.5MM
Matt Vierling (Tigers): $3.7MM
Starting Pitchers
Ronel Blanco (Astros): $1.4MM
Kutter Crawford (Red Sox): $2.8MM
Ryan Feltner (Rockies): $3.8MM
Bowden Francis (Blue Jays): $1.3MM
Braxton Garrett (Cubs): $1.6MM
Luis Gil (Yankees): $2.3MM
Josiah Gray (Nationals): $1.6MM
Tanner Houck (Red Sox): $4.1MM
Jake Irvin (Nationals): $3.4MM
Tylor Megill (Mets): $2.5MM
Bailey Ober (Twins): $6.9MM
Mitchell Parker (Braves): $1.1MM
Grayson Rodriguez (Angels): $2.1MM
Jesse Scholtens (Rays): $900K
JP Sears (Padres): $2.8MM
Joey Wentz (Braves): $900K
Brandon Williamson (Reds): $1.3MM
Right-Handed Relievers
Jake Bird (Nationals): $1.3MM
Beau Brieske (Tigers): $1.5MM
Jhony Brito (Padres): $800K
José Buttó (Rangers): $800K
Jake Cousins (Dodgers): $1MM
Cooper Criswell (Mariners): $900K
Camilo Doval (Giants): $6.6MM
Lucas Erceg (Royals): $2.3MM
Michael Grove (Braves): $1MM
Jimmy Herget (Rockies): $2.4MM
Bryan Hoeing (Padres): $800K
James Karinchak (Braves): $1.1MM
Jordan Leasure (White Sox): $1MM
James McArthur (Royals): $800K
Nick Mears (Royals): $2.2MM
Nate Pearson (Royals): $2MM
Ethan Roberts (Cubs): $800K
Manuel Rodríguez (Rays): $900K
Michael Rucker (Mariners): $800K
Cole Sands (Twins): $1.3MM
Tony Santillan (Reds): $2.5MM
Cole Sulser (Rays): $1.9MM
Edwin Uceta (Rays): $1.5MM
Will Vest (Tigers): $4.4MM
Rowan Wick (Giants): $800K
Left-Handed Relievers
Tanner Banks (Phillies): $1.4MM
Garrett Cleavinger (Rays): $3.7MM
Anthony Gose (Royals): $1.1MM
Chris Murphy (White Sox): $900K
Andrew Nardi (Marlins): $1.1MM
Cionel Pérez (Mets): $1.2MM
Bennett Sousa (Astros): $1.3MM
https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2026/11/ ... dates.html
-
Seattle or Bust
- Posts: 12105
- Joined: Wed Mar 09, 2022 7:09 pm
Re: 2026-27 Hot Stove Thread
For people who don't think Kirby has trade value...
Dustin May... who has only exceeded 140 innings once in his career and is worth a career 2.9 WAR... who also put up just .4 WAR in '26 with a 4.70 ERA... including -0.3 WAR in the second half... just signed a 3-year $50M deal.
Kirby, who has pitched 170 innings 3 out of 4 years that weren't his rookie season and 190 innings twice... who has been worth 9.4 bWAR and a career 3.74 ERA... won't make the $16.7 avg that Dustin May is making in the next 2 years.
Dustin May... who has only exceeded 140 innings once in his career and is worth a career 2.9 WAR... who also put up just .4 WAR in '26 with a 4.70 ERA... including -0.3 WAR in the second half... just signed a 3-year $50M deal.
Kirby, who has pitched 170 innings 3 out of 4 years that weren't his rookie season and 190 innings twice... who has been worth 9.4 bWAR and a career 3.74 ERA... won't make the $16.7 avg that Dustin May is making in the next 2 years.